Rabbis say Mamdani listened to them. Now they’re waiting on his plan to fight antisemitism.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani is trying to repair a troubled relationship with some Jewish New Yorkers without backing away from the positions on Israel and Palestine that have long been central to his politics — a balancing act that came into sharp focus during a private meeting with 10 rabbis earlier this week.

Four participants who took part in the closed-door, no-camera meeting, in speaking with amNewYork, described broad agreement among them that many Jewish New Yorkers do not feel the safety and belonging that Mamdani says he wants for them, but sharply different ideas about what the mayor should change.